How do you lead a journal club discussion?
Summarise the author’s conclusions. Say whether or not you find the paper convincing. If the audience has not chipped in by now, highlight points that your audience might want to discuss, or ask them questions about what they thought about particular aspects of the paper.
What do you do in a journal club?
Journal club presentations provide a forum through which hematology trainees keep abreast of new developments in hematology and engage in informal discussion and interaction. Furthermore, honing presentation skills and mastering the ability to critically appraise the evidence add to our armamentarium as clinicians.
What makes evidence based journal clubs succeed?
JOURNAL CLUB PRINCIPLES Focus on the current real patient problems of most interest to the group. Bring questions, a sense of humour, and good food. Distribute (and redistribute) the time, place, topics, and roles. Bring enough copies for everyone of both the week’s article and a backup article.
What should I ask a journal club?
Core Questions for Journal Club
- Type of study and study design.
- Source of funding.
- Sample selection strategy and characteristics of sample.
- Analytical approach used.
- How generalizable are results?
- How would you discuss the findings with patients? For study enrollment? For application of study results to the patient’s care?
How do you succeed in journal club?
JOURNAL CLUB PRINCIPLES
- Focus on the current real patient problems of most interest to the group.
- Bring questions, a sense of humour, and good food.
- Distribute (and redistribute) the time, place, topics, and roles.
- Bring enough copies for everyone of both the week’s article and a backup article.
What is the role of a journal club facilitator?
At the end of each journal club activity, the facilitator summarizes the learning points, recommendations, and the action plan if the group believes changes to current clinical practice are recommended3.